Welcome to our Monthly Journal Club! Each month I post a paper or two that I have read and find interesting. I use this as a forum for open discussion about the paper in question. Anyone can participate in the journal club, and provide comments/critiques on the paper. This month’s paper is “T cells in patients with narcolepsy target self-antigens of hypocretin neurons” by Frederica Sallusto and colleagues at ETH-Zurich. I will provide a brief overview of the techniques/approaches used to make it more understandable to potential non-expert readers. If I am not familiar with something, I’ll simply say so.
Narcolepsy is a relatively rare neurological disease caused by the selective destruction of hypocretin (hcrt; also known as orexin) neurons in the lateral hypothalamus. Destruction of these neurons causes patients to experience excessive daytime sleepiness, cataplexy (spontaneous loss of muscle tone), dream-like hallucinations, and sleep paralysis. There is a strong genetic association between development of narcolepsy and specific genotypes of the antigen presentation complex HLA-DQB1 (HLA-DQB1*06:02), additional evidence of immune dysfunction, and increased incidence of the disease following influenza vaccination. These findings suggest a role for the immune system in the etiology of narcolepsy. Indeed, the hunt for autoreactive T-cells targeting hypocretin or hypocretin receptors has been on for over a decade. The present paper fills this gap by empirically showing that patients with sporadic narcolepsy have CD4+ T-cells that target hypocretin, essentially proving an autoimmune etiology for this disease.
This has been a hard problem to crack as five epitopes from the hcrt precursors were predicted to bind HLA-DQB1*06:02, however a recent study failed to find evidence of auto-reactive CD4+ T-cell targeting of hcrt precursors (Kornum et al., 2017). Additionally, a study claiming to find CD4+ T-cell mediated autoimmunity targeting hcrt and cross-reactivity to an epitope present on the 2009 H1N1 influenza virus was retracted when the authors failed to replicate their own findings (de la Herran-Arita et al., 2014). Others have demonstrated (in mouse models) that H1N1 infection can lead to narcolepsy-like symptoms in mice (Tesoriero et al, 2015), and reprogramming of T-cells to target hypocretin neurons leads to their destruction and the development of a narcolepsy phenotype (Bernard-Valnet et al., 2016).
Sallusto and colleagues began by obtaining peripheral blood samples from 16 patients with narcolepsy (and who had the HLA-DQB1*06:02 allele) and complementary healthy controls (also containing the putative autoimmune allele). As autoreactive T-cells are extremely rare to begin with, they began by sorting memory T cells (CD45RA− CD4+) to high purity (>98%), through labeling them with carboxyfluorescein succinimidyl ester (CFSE). These cells were then ‘pulsed’ with antigen presenting cells (APCs; monocytes) containing different amino acid sequences of the protein precursor (pre-prohypocretin) to Hcrt-1 and Hcrt-2. This method only showed 1 patient with an ‘activated’ response of the T cells to stimulation with APCs containing peptides of pre-prohypocretin. Dissatisfied with this result, the authors tried a more sensitive approach through generated ‘T cell libraries’.
When autoreactive T cells from narcoleptics were pulsed with B cells containing a ‘hypocretin peptide pool’, nearly all (all but one) patient samples showed a strong response to hcrt peptides, indicating that they indeed recognized and responded to this amino acid sequence. In contrast, there were only 3 (out of 12) proliferating responses in control patient samples. Regardless, the magnitude of the response was much higher in narcoleptics than in controls. This approach let them determine that the frequency of the hcrt-reactive T cells was very small (~21.4 cells per 10,000,000 CD4+ T cells). Interestingly, these autoreactive T cells were also found in patients lacking the HLA-DQB1*06:02 allele, and those without hcrt deficiency.
To investigate further, the researchers examined whether these patients also had autoreactive T cells targeting another protein highly expressed in hypocretin-neurons, called tribbles homologue 2 (TRIB2). Indeed, patient T cells showed a highly proliferative response to stimulation with pieces of this protein as well. The authors further confirmed ‘killer’ CD8+ T cell responses to hypocretin peptides from patient samples, but not controls. They further characterized these cells by examining what proteins they secrete and what mRNAs they transcribe in response to hcrt stimulation.
By analyzing the T-cell receptor β -chain variable region (TRBV) in each T cell clone, the authors demonstrated that these autoreactive T cells are not homogenous, and target multiple epitopes along hcrt-1 and hcrt-2. Finally, and importantly the authors failed to find evidence for ‘molecular mimicry’ between hcrt and influenza antigens, as T-cells from patients with narcolepsy failed to proliferate in response to an influenza vaccine containing A/California/7/2009 H1N1 strains or to one containing CA09 H1 haemagglutinin. Therefore, the association between vaccination and the development of narcolepsy still remains a mystery.
Click the post title to join the discussion and leave comments!